Family files lawsuits in shooting death
In June, Nicholas D. Bell, 25, of Manchester, was sentenced to serve a year in prison for simple assault, and reckless endangerment, while a seven-year deferred sentence was placed on him for a manslaughter charge. Bell pleaded no contest to the charges in May. According to police, on Thanksgiving Day two years ago, Bell and Jeffrey R. Charbonneau, 24 at the time of his death, were at the home of the Goodwin family on Eagle Rise Road in Manchester where they were both staying for the holiday. Police said Bell took what he thought was an air rifle, but was actually a .22 caliber rifle, and shot Charbonneau with it as a prank. Charbonneau was killed.
According to a complaint filed in Bennington Superior Court Civil Division on Oct. 23 by Rutland attorney David L. Cleary, on behalf of Charbonneau's parents, Richard and Betty Charbonneau, Bell negligently caused the death of their son and is responsible for damages through a wrongful death claim.
The filing contains a response from Bell himself. In response to Cleary's claim "On or about November 25, 2010, defendant negligently caused the death of Jeffrey Charbonneau," Bell wrote "I accidentally caused the death of Jeffrey Charbonneau."
Bell is currently being held at the Northern State Correctional Facility in Newport.
Cleary filed a second complaint on Oct. 31, this one naming James Goodwin, Carolyn Goodwin, and James Goodwin Jr. as defendants. Cleary claims Charbonneau's death was a result of the Goodwin's not keeping a loaded firearm in a safe and secure manner.
"At that time and place, the defendants and each of them had the responsibility to maintain the firearm in a non-lethally dangerous condition by either containing it in an unloaded condition, or by maintaining it in a locked and inoperable condition," Cleary wrote.
Both suits request compensation for damages to the Charbonneaus.
John Paul Faigant, an attorney for the Goodwin's, filed a response to the complaint on Nov. 29. In it, Faigant denies the Charbonneau's claims and cites a number of defenses, including "Conduct on behalf of others for whom these Defendants are neither responsible in law or fact," as well as Chapter 1 Article 16 of the Vermont Constitution and the United State Constitution Second Amendment.
TALK TO US
If you'd like to leave a comment (or a tip or a question) about this story with the editors, please email us. We also welcome letters to the editor for publication; you can do that by filling out our letters form and submitting it to the newsroom.